How We Sift
Every recipe and every site is judged the same way. Here’s what we look for.
Judging a recipe
- Exact measurements, not guesses
- A method that makes sense on paper
- Comments from cooks who actually made it
- Real photos of real food
Judging a site
- Reliability across many recipes, not just one
- How hard ads and pop-ups make it to cook from
- A jump-to-recipe button, or a short preamble
- No AI-generated photos passed off as real
Our verdicts
- Make it
- The best version we found. Follow it as written.
- Good with tweaks
- Worth making with the changes we note.
- Sifted Blend
- The best dinner came from combining recipes. We tell you which part to take from each.
- Sifted out
- Not worth your time, and we say why.
We never copy a recipe
We tell you which version to make and why, then send you to the cook who wrote it. They get the visit and the credit.